Indian Company Master Data Made Simple
Post Office RD Calculator
Recurring Deposit Calculator
RD Details
Current Interest Rate: 6.7% p.a.
Post Office RD offers quarterly compounding with safe and guaranteed returns.
Minimum: ₹100 per month
Current Post Office RD rate: 6.7% p.a. (compounded quarterly)
Maturity Details
Investment Breakdown
Formula Used:
M = P × [(1 + r/n)^(nt) - 1] / (1 - (1 + r/n)^(-1/3))
Where M = Maturity, P = Monthly Deposit, r = Annual Rate, n = Compounding Frequency, t = Tenure
Key Features of Post Office RD
- Safe and government-backed investment
- Minimum deposit: ₹100 per month
- Tenure: 5 years (can be extended)
- Interest compounded quarterly
- Premature withdrawal allowed with penalty
- Loan facility available (up to 50% of balance)
Post Office RD Calculator: Recurring Deposit Complete Guide
The Post Office Recurring Deposit (RD) Calculator is an essential tool for disciplined savers seeking government-guaranteed safe returns through monthly systematic savings with quarterly compounding. Post Office RD is one of India's most trusted investment schemes offering capital protection (100% sovereign guarantee), predictable returns (6.7% current rate as of Q3 FY 2024-25), flexible monthly deposits (minimum ₹100, no maximum limit), and 5-year tenure with extension option. Unlike lump sum investments like FDs, RD suits salaried individuals with monthly surplus income, allowing disciplined wealth accumulation through small regular deposits—ideal for middle-class families saving for child's education, first-time homebuyers building down payment corpus, young professionals starting investment journey with limited capital, and goal-based savers targeting specific milestones (wedding, car purchase, vacation fund) 1-5 years away.
Understanding Post Office RD is crucial for maximizing systematic savings—6.7% quarterly compounded on 5-year RD = 6.87% effective annual rate (higher than savings accounts 3-4% but lower than FDs 7.5% due to progressive deposit nature), government backing (zero default risk unlike bank RDs from private banks), disciplined savings habit formation (monthly deposit commitment prevents impulsive spending), and loan facility (50% of balance after 12 months for emergencies). Post Office RD stands out with extremely low minimum deposit (₹100/month accessible to everyone), sovereign guarantee (Government of India backing vs. bank DICGC ₹5L insurance), flexible deposit amounts (can open multiple RDs with different monthly amounts), senior citizen premium (additional 0.50% extra interest for citizens 60+ years = 7.2% for seniors!), and premature withdrawal allowed (after 3 years with minor penalty for liquidity).
This free Post Office RD Calculator helps estimate maturity amount, total interest earned, investment breakdown, and wealth gain percentage based on monthly deposit (₹100 minimum), tenure (1-5 years), and current interest rate (6.7%). Whether you're a salaried professional depositing ₹10,000 monthly in 5-year RD to build ₹7.11L corpus for child's higher education, housewife saving ₹2,000/month from household budget for family vacation fund, young couple contributing ₹15,000 monthly towards home down payment in 3 years, or comparing Post Office RD against bank RDs/SIPs, accurate calculation enables optimal goal-based systematic savings through India's most accessible government-backed recurring deposit scheme!
Understanding Post Office RD Components
Monthly Deposit & Flexibility
Minimum Deposit: ₹100 per month (₹10/month in some rural post offices historically, now standardized ₹100)—extremely accessible for small savers, domestic helpers, daily wage workers. Maximum Deposit: No upper limit (can deposit ₹1L, ₹2L monthly if surplus available)—unlike PPF ₹1.5L annual cap. Multiple RDs: Can open unlimited RDs in same/different post offices—strategic: Open ₹5k RD for child education + ₹3k RD for vacation fund + ₹2k RD for emergency corpus (3 separate RDs maturing at different times for staggered liquidity). Deposit Flexibility: Must deposit by 15th of each month to avoid default. Miss deposit → Pay ₹1 penalty per ₹100 deposit per month delayed (e.g., ₹5k deposit 2 months late = ₹100 penalty). Miss 4+ consecutive months → Account discontinued (can be revived with penalty). Strategic Tip: Set auto-debit from salary account on 1st of month (post-salary credit) to never miss deposit—ensures discipline + avoids penalties!
Interest Rate & Compounding
Current Rate: 6.7% p.a. (Q3 FY 2024-25), revised quarterly by Ministry of Finance aligned with government security yields. Historical Rates: Ranged 5.8-7.3% last 10 years—relatively stable compared to market-linked returns. Compounding: Quarterly (every 3 months)—interest calculated on progressive deposits, compounded quarterly, credited at maturity. Progressive Calculation: Unlike FD (lump sum earning interest from Day 1), RD deposits accumulate monthly—Month 1 deposit earns interest for 60 months, Month 2 for 59 months, etc. Month 60 deposit earns interest for only 1 month! This progressive nature makes RD interest lower than FD for same rate. Effective Rate: 6.7% quarterly compounded = 6.87% effective annual rate. Senior Citizen Benefit: Additional 0.50% for citizens 60+ years—RD becomes 7.2% for seniors (₹10k/month × 5 years = ₹7.18L maturity vs. ₹7.11L regular = ₹7,000 extra!). Tax Implication: Interest fully taxable as "Income from Other Sources"—TDS @ 10% if annual interest exceeds ₹40,000 (₹50,000 for seniors).
Tenure & Extension
Standard Tenure: 5 years (60 months) mandatory for new RD accounts opened (earlier 1/2/3/5-year options available, now standardized to 5 years only since 2023 rules). Extension Option: After 5-year maturity, can extend RD for another 5 years in blocks—must continue monthly deposits during extension at same amount, earns prevailing interest rate at extension time (not opening rate). Example: ₹5k/month RD opened 2020 @ 5.8% matures 2025 to ₹3.5L → Extend 5 years @ 6.7% new rate → By 2030, additional ₹3.92L from fresh deposits + ₹7.42L total corpus! Maturity Calculation: RD matures exactly after 60 months (5 years) from opening date—if opened Jan 15, 2025, matures Jan 15, 2030. Auto-Renewal: Not available—must explicitly apply for extension before maturity, else corpus credited to savings account and RD closed.
Premature Withdrawal & Closure
Minimum Lock-In: 3 years (36 months)—cannot withdraw before 3 years except in case of account holder's death. After 3 Years: Premature withdrawal allowed with penalty—interest rate reduced by 1% for tenure completed. Example: ₹10k/month RD @ 6.7%, closed after 4 years (48 months) → Total deposits ₹4.8L, interest recalculated @ 5.7% (6.7% - 1% penalty) instead of 6.7%—you lose ₹19,000 interest! Death Exception: On account holder's death, nominee/legal heir can withdraw full maturity amount without penalty at contracted rate anytime (no 3-year lock-in applies). Discontinuation: If account discontinued due to missed deposits (4+ consecutive months), can withdraw accumulated deposits + reduced interest (rate applicable for period money remained in account). Strategic Tip: If urgent liquidity needed, prefer taking loan against RD (50% of balance after 12 months) instead of premature closure—saves penalty, maintains RD for goal completion!
Loan Against RD
Loan Eligibility: Available after 12 months (1 year) of RD opening—must have completed minimum 12 deposits to qualify. Loan Amount: Up to 50% of accumulated balance (deposits + interest earned till date). Example: ₹5k/month RD, after 24 months deposits = ₹1.2L + interest ₹8k = ₹1.28L balance → Loan ₹64,000 available (50% of ₹1.28L). Interest Rate on Loan: RD interest rate + 2% (e.g., 6.7% RD → 8.7% loan rate)—higher than FD loan (FD rate + 1%) but still cheaper than personal loans (12-16%). Repayment: No fixed EMI—flexible repayment anytime, interest calculated daily. If loan not repaid by RD maturity, loan principal + interest auto-deducted from maturity amount. Use Case: ₹10k/month RD for child's education, Year 3 urgent ₹1L needed for medical emergency—take ₹1L loan @ 8.7% vs. breaking RD (lose ₹19k penalty + goal disrupted). Loan preserves RD goal, repay from bonus/increment later!
RD vs. FD vs. SIP Comparison
Post Office RD vs. FD: RD suits monthly surplus (₹5k/month over 5 years), FD suits lump sum (₹3L one-time). RD 6.7% < FD 7.5% because progressive deposits vs. lump sum. RD builds discipline, FD requires capital upfront. RD flexible (start ₹100/month), FD needs minimum ₹1k. Both government-backed, sovereign guarantee. vs. Bank RD: PO RD offers 6.7% vs. bank RD 5.5-6.5% (0.2-1.2% higher!), sovereign guarantee vs. DICGC ₹5L insurance, senior premium 0.5% (many banks offer 0.25% only). But bank RDs have net banking (online deposit), auto-debit facility, instant statements—PO RD requires branch visit for monthly deposit (unless using Internet Banking for select accounts). vs. Equity SIP: RD 6.7% guaranteed vs. SIP 12-15% volatile (can be negative in bad years!). RD capital protected (sovereign guarantee), SIP market risk (2020 COVID crash -40%!). RD suitable for short-term goals (1-5 years) where capital protection critical, SIP for long-term wealth (10+ years) where market volatility acceptable. Optimal Strategy: Combine—₹5k/month RD for 5-year child education goal (guaranteed ₹3.56L) + ₹5k/month equity SIP for 15-year retirement (expected ₹25L @ 15% CAGR but risky). Diversifies risk + return!
How to Use the Post Office RD Calculator
- Enter Monthly Deposit Amount: Input the amount you plan to deposit every month (minimum ₹100, no maximum limit). Use slider for quick adjustments or type exact amount. Ensure this amount is sustainable from monthly income/surplus—don't overcommit and default (₹1 penalty per ₹100 per month delayed!). Consider fixed expenses (rent, EMI, groceries), variable expenses (entertainment, dining), savings (RD allocation), and emergency buffer (3-6 months expenses separate). Example: Salary ₹50k/month, expenses ₹35k, surplus ₹15k → Allocate ₹10k to RD (safe), keep ₹5k for contingencies/liquidity. Starting ₹10,000 monthly RD → Enter "10000" in deposit field.
- Select Tenure: Choose investment period from dropdown—1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 years. Current Post Office RD rules mandate 5-year tenure for new accounts (earlier 1/2/3-year options discontinued), but calculator allows testing different scenarios. Align tenure with goal timeline: Child's school admission 3 years away → Select "3 Years" (though actual PO RD will be 5 years, can premature close after 3 years with penalty if needed). Longer tenure = more interest accumulation due to compounding on progressive deposits. Example: ₹10k/month, 3 years = ₹3.85L maturity vs. 5 years = ₹7.11L maturity—longer commitment doubles wealth!
- Adjust Interest Rate (If Needed): Calculator pre-fills current rate (6.7% as of Q3 FY 2024-25), but you can manually adjust if: (a) You're senior citizen (60+ years) → Add 0.50% to standard rate (becomes 7.2%), (b) Rates changed in new quarter → Update to latest rate from indiapost.gov.in, (c) Exploring different scenarios → Test impact of rate hikes/cuts on maturity (e.g., if RBI increases rates, PO RD rate may go to 7.0-7.2%). Interest rate field accepts 1-15% range in 0.1% increments. Note: Post Office RD rate revised quarterly (April/July/October/January) based on government security yields—track rate changes for optimal RD opening timing (open when rates high for long-term lock-in!).
- Calculate Maturity: Click "Calculate Maturity" button to compute results instantly. Calculator uses RD formula: M = P × [((1 + r/4)^(n×4) - 1) / (1 - (1 + r/4)^(-1/3))], where M = Maturity, P = Monthly Deposit, r = Annual Rate, n = Tenure (years), 4 = Quarterly compounding. Result section displays: (a) Maturity Amount = Total deposits + Interest earned, (b) Total Deposits = Monthly deposit × Number of months, (c) Interest Earned = Maturity - Deposits, (d) Investment Breakdown = Deposits % vs. Interest % (visual chart showing deposit contribution vs. interest contribution to maturity). Example: ₹10k/month, 5 years, 6.7% → Maturity ₹7,11,176, Deposits ₹6L, Interest ₹1,11,176 (15.6% gain over 5 years!).
- Analyze Investment Breakdown: Review the visual chart showing total deposits percentage (blue) vs. interest percentage (green) of maturity amount. For RDs, deposit contribution is high (80-85%) and interest contribution moderate (15-20%) compared to FDs (deposit 60-70%, interest 30-40%) because RD deposits progressive (later deposits earn less interest vs. FD lump sum earning from Day 1). Longer tenure and higher rate = larger interest component. For 5-year RD @ 6.7%, interest contributes ~15-20% of maturity. Compare this against your goal requirement—if goal is ₹8L in 5 years, ₹10k/month RD gives ₹7.11L (₹89k shortfall!)—you need ₹11,250/month deposit to reach ₹8L target. Calculator helps reverse-engineer required monthly deposit for goal amount.
- Compare Scenarios & Plan: Use "Reset" button to clear inputs and test multiple scenarios: (a) Compare tenures—₹10k/month in 3-year RD @ 6.7% = ₹3.85L vs. 5-year = ₹7.11L (5-year earns ₹2.15L more interest from longer compounding!). (b) Compare deposits—₹5k/month vs. ₹10k/month vs. ₹15k/month for same 5-year tenure (₹3.56L vs. ₹7.11L vs. ₹10.67L maturity—linear scaling but compound interest benefit!). (c) Senior citizen advantage—₹10k/month 5-year RD @ 7.2% (senior) = ₹7.18L vs. ₹7.11L @ 6.7% (regular)—extra ₹7,000 gain for seniors! (d) RD vs. FD comparison—₹10k/month × 60 months = ₹6L total → If deposited as lump sum ₹6L in FD @ 7.5% for 5 years = ₹8.68L vs. RD ₹7.11L—FD wins IF you have lump sum, but RD wins if you earn monthly salary (can't deposit ₹6L upfront!). RD suits income earners, FD suits lump sum holders. Download results or note down for post office visit to open RD account.
Practical Example: Young Couple Saving for Home Down Payment
Scenario: Rahul (28) and Priya (26), young couple working in IT sector (combined income ₹1.2L/month), living in rented apartment (₹20k rent), planning to buy first home in 5 years. They need ₹15L down payment (20% of ₹75L flat in suburban Mumbai). After expenses (₹55k), EMI (₹15k car loan), entertainment (₹10k), they have ₹40k monthly surplus. Financial advisor recommends Post Office RD for disciplined, guaranteed down payment savings.
| RD Details | Monthly Deposit | Tenure | Rate | Maturity Amount | Interest Earned |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rahul's RD (Individual) | ₹15,000 | 5 Years | 6.7% | ₹10,66,764 | ₹1,66,764 |
| Priya's RD (Individual) | ₹15,000 | 5 Years | 6.7% | ₹10,66,764 | ₹1,66,764 |
| Joint RD (Emergency Backup) | ₹5,000 | 5 Years | 6.7% | ₹3,55,588 | ₹55,588 |
| Total Savings | ₹35,000/month | 5 Years | 6.7% | ₹24,89,116 | ₹3,89,116 |
| Down Payment Goal | ₹15,00,000 Required | ||||
| Surplus after Down Payment | ₹9,89,116 Extra! | ||||
Key Insights:
- Goal Achievement + Surplus: ₹35k/month deposits over 5 years create ₹24.89L corpus—far exceeding ₹15L down payment goal! Surplus ₹9.89L can be used for: (a) Home registration/stamp duty (7-8% of property value = ₹5.25L), (b) Interior furnishing (₹3L), (c) Emergency home maintenance fund (₹1.5L). RD calculator helped Rahul-Priya realize ₹35k monthly commitment not only meets goal but provides buffer—better than falling short and scrambling for funds at purchase time!
- Separate RDs Strategy: Instead of single joint RD (₹35k/month), they opened 2 individual + 1 joint RD for tax and flexibility benefits: (a) Individual RDs allow both to claim separate Post Office Savings Account benefits (₹3.5k annual interest exempt under Section 80TTA for each), (b) Separate RDs provide liquidity flexibility—if Rahul faces emergency Year 3, can take loan against his RD without disturbing Priya's RD, (c) Joint RD acts as backup—if one person loses job/income drops, other continues deposits in joint RD (min ₹5k commitment manageable even with 50% income loss). This diversification protects goal even if one income stream disrupted!
- Discipline Over Market Risk: Rahul-Priya considered equity SIP for higher returns (12-15% vs. RD 6.7%) but rejected due to: (a) Short 5-year horizon—equity volatile for < 7 years (2020 COVID crash would've delayed home purchase if corpus dropped 30-40%!), (b) Goal criticality—home down payment non-negotiable milestone (can't postpone wedding/child's admission if market crashes), (c) Sleep-at-night factor—guaranteed RD maturity ₹24.89L provides certainty vs. SIP's ₹18-32L range depending on market performance. RD's lower returns acceptable trade-off for capital protection + predictability. They allocated separate ₹5k/month to equity SIP for long-term retirement (15+ years) where volatility acceptable.
- Automatic Discipline Mechanism: Rahul-Priya set auto-debit from salary accounts on 3rd of every month (both receive salary on 1st)—ensures RD deposits never missed even if they forget/travel/busy. Post Office Internet Banking enabled for statement tracking. They treat RD deposits as fixed expense (like rent/EMI) not optional savings—mindset shift: "Pay yourself (savings) first before spending". This discipline prevented lifestyle inflation (avoiding ₹40k monthly surplus = ₹40k extra spending)—channeled into wealth creation instead. 5 years later, they'll have home down payment + ₹10L emergency fund vs. friends with similar income still renting without savings!
- Tax Implications: Interest ₹3.89L over 5 years = ₹77,820 annual average, fully taxable as "Income from Other Sources". At 20.8% bracket (combined income ₹1.2L/month = ₹14.4L annual), tax on RD interest = ₹16,187 annually (net interest ₹61,633). TDS @ 10% deducted quarterly if interest exceeds ₹40k annually (likely on combined RDs)—they submit Form 15G to avoid TDS since total income below threshold after deductions. Post-tax effective return = 6.7% × (1 - 0.208) = 5.31%—still beats savings account 3-4% and safer than volatile equity! For high-income earners (31.2% bracket), RD post-tax return drops to 4.61%—consider PPF 7.1% tax-free for better post-tax efficiency (but 15-year lock-in vs. RD 5-year).
- Alternative Scenario—If Income Drops: If Rahul loses job Year 2 (24 months deposited, ₹8.4L in individual RD), they can: (a) Continue Rahul's RD from emergency fund for 6-12 months till re-employment (avoid discontinuation penalty), (b) Stop Rahul's RD, pay ₹1/₹100 penalty (₹150/month for ₹15k deposit) till re-employment (cheaper than premature closure), (c) Take loan against Rahul's RD (50% of ₹8.4L = ₹4.2L) for income replacement while job hunting, (d) Priya continues her RD + joint RD (₹20k/month manageable on single income), ensuring at least ₹14.22L corpus by Year 5 (94.8% of goal!). This contingency planning ensures goal survives income shock—key reason for separate RDs instead of single large RD!
Important Note: Post Office RD interest is fully taxable annually (even though interest received only at maturity) under "Income from Other Sources". TDS @ 10% deducted if annual interest exceeds ₹40,000 (₹50,000 for senior citizens). For Rahul-Priya's combined RDs, TDS applicable from Year 3 onward when annual interest crosses ₹40k threshold—they must plan for TDS deduction or file quarterly TDS exemption forms if total income low. Unlike PPF (EEE tax-free), RD interest reduces net returns for high-income earners (31.2% bracket: 6.7% becomes 4.61% post-tax). However, RD's shorter 5-year tenure vs. PPF's 15-year lock-in makes it suitable for medium-term goals where capital protection critical and liquidity needed within 3-5 years. For tax optimization, consider allocating max ₹1.5L annually to PPF (tax-free) for long-term goals (retirement 15+ years away) + remaining surplus to RD (taxable but liquid) for medium-term goals (home, car, child's school admission 3-7 years away)—balanced approach maximizes tax efficiency + goal-based liquidity!
Why Post Office RD Calculations Matter for Financial Planning
- Disciplined Systematic Savings for Goal Achievement: Post Office RD enforces monthly deposit commitment (₹100-₹50k/month), building disciplined savings habit crucial for goal-based financial planning—child's education fund (3-15 years), home down payment (5-7 years), car purchase (2-3 years), wedding expenses (1-5 years), or vacation fund (1-2 years). Unlike one-time lump sum investments (FD requires ₹3L upfront), RD suits salaried individuals with monthly surplus income—deposit ₹5k-10k from salary every month, accumulate substantial corpus over time without feeling financial strain. RD calculator helps reverse-engineer required monthly deposit for goal amount: Need ₹10L in 5 years? Calculator shows ₹14,100/month needed @ 6.7%—if current salary allows only ₹10k/month, either extend tenure to 7 years OR supplement with additional income/bonus to bridge ₹4.1k/month gap. Critical for goals that cannot be postponed (child's school admission date fixed, wedding date fixed, home purchase opportunity limited)—RD guarantees corpus availability when needed, unlike volatile equity SIPs that may crash right before goal maturity (2020 COVID destroyed 40% wealth for investors needing funds March 2020!).
- Capital Protection for Risk-Averse & Short-Term Goals: RD offers 100% capital protection with sovereign guarantee (Government of India backing)—ideal for risk-averse investors unable to tolerate market volatility (retirees with no earning capacity to recover losses, single-income families with no backup savings, conservative savers prioritizing capital preservation over aggressive returns). For short-term goals (1-5 years), RD's guaranteed 6.7% return beats savings accounts (3-4% stagnant money), liquid funds (5-7% but volatile NAV risk), and equity SIPs (12-15% average but can be -30% to +50% in any given year!). RD calculator quantifies certainty advantage: ₹10k/month for 3 years = ₹3.85L guaranteed maturity—plan child's school admission expenses confidently. Equity SIP same ₹10k/month could be ₹3.2L (if market crashes) to ₹4.5L (if market booms)—₹65k shortfall risk unacceptable if school fees payment deadline non-negotiable! RD eliminates uncertainty for time-bound goals, ensuring goal achievement regardless of market conditions, economic downturns, or banking sector crises.
- Accessible Entry Point for Small Savers & First-Time Investors: RD's ₹100 minimum monthly deposit makes it most accessible investment in India—daily wage workers earning ₹500/day can save ₹100/month (20% savings rate), domestic helpers earning ₹8k/month can deposit ₹500/month, entry-level professionals earning ₹25k can start ₹2k/month RD while learning about investing. RD calculator helps small savers visualize wealth creation: ₹500/month for 5 years = ₹35,559 maturity (₹5,559 interest earned!)—for someone earning ₹10k/month, this ₹35k corpus is transformational (covers 3 months emergency expenses, child's school fees, medical emergency, or festival expenses). RD's simplicity (no stock market knowledge needed, no NAV/portfolio tracking required, just deposit ₹X every month) reduces psychological barrier to investing vs. intimidating equity mutual funds/stocks. RD teaches financial discipline—delaying gratification (reduce ₹500 monthly entertainment spending, redirect to RD), goal-setting (save for specific milestone), delayed reward (maturity after 5 years). For many Indians, RD is first formal savings instrument beyond savings account—gateway to advanced investing (PPF, FDs, bonds, equities) once confidence + capital built. Without RD, small savers keep cash at home (zero returns, theft risk) or overspend (no savings)—RD channelizes surplus into government-guaranteed wealth creation.
- Retirement Income Supplementation (Pensioners & Seniors): Senior citizens (60+ years) get 0.50% extra interest premium on Post Office RD (7.2% for seniors vs. 6.7% regular)—one of highest safe returns in India for retirees. RD calculator helps pensioners design staggered RD ladders: Open 3 separate RDs—₹5k/month for 1 year (Year 1), ₹5k/month for 3 years (Year 1-3), ₹5k/month for 5 years (Year 1-5)—creates maturity every 1-2 years providing liquidity without premature withdrawal penalties. For retirees with pension income (₹30k/month), allocating ₹10k-15k to RD builds medical emergency corpus (₹7.18L after 5 years from ₹10k/month @ 7.2% senior rate = ₹7.18L covers 2 major surgeries @ ₹3.5L each!). RD also teaches retirees' children/grandchildren disciplined savings—grandparent opens ₹500/month RD in grandchild's name (minor account), teaches importance of regular savings, matures to ₹35,559 when child turns 13-15 (covers school books, coaching fees, or first laptop!). RD's government backing critical for seniors who lived through bank failures (1990s Punjab National Bank scam, 2000s private bank collapses)—prefer Post Office sovereign guarantee over bank DICGC ₹5L insurance for deposits > ₹5L. Unlike volatile pension mutual funds (NAV fluctuates, retirees panic during market crashes), RD provides predictable 6-7% returns enabling budgeting for future expenses (inflation-adjusted lifts, medical equipment, home repairs) without market risk exposure.
- Emergency Fund Building (Liquidity + Returns Balance): RD provides better returns (6.7%) than savings accounts (3-4%) for emergency fund parking while maintaining decent liquidity through loan facility (50% of balance after 12 months). RD calculator helps design emergency RD: ₹5k/month for 3 years = ₹1.93L corpus (covers 6 months expenses @ ₹32k/month for ₹25k salary earner). Unlike PPF (15-year lock-in, withdrawal only after Year 7) or FDs (premature withdrawal penalty 1%), RD allows loan against deposits (available from Year 1 onward after 12 deposits completed)—borrow 50% of balance @ 8.7% (RD rate + 2%) for medical emergency, job loss income replacement, urgent home repairs, or vehicle breakdown without breaking RD and losing interest. RD loan cheaper than personal loans (12-16%), credit cards (36-42%!), or gold loans (9-12%)—₹1L RD balance allows ₹50k loan @ 8.7% vs. personal loan ₹50k @ 14% saves ₹2,650 interest over 1 year! RD's monthly deposit nature suits emergency fund philosophy (build gradually, not overnight)—salaried professionals allocate ₹5k-10k monthly, accumulate ₹3-6L emergency corpus over 3-5 years while earning 6.7% vs. savings account 3.5% (₹15k extra interest on ₹3L over 3 years!). For dual-income families, one person's RD designated as emergency fund (never touched unless crisis), other person's RD for goal-based savings (child education, vacation)—segregation ensures emergency funds not diverted to lifestyle spending.
- Comparison with Alternative Systematic Savings Options: RD calculator facilitates comparing Post Office RD against Bank RDs (typically 5.5-6.5% vs. PO 6.7%—₹10k/month 5-year bank RD @ 6.0% = ₹6.98L vs. PO @ 6.7% = ₹7.11L, PO earns ₹13,000 extra!), Equity SIPs (12-15% average but volatile—can be -30% to +50% annually, suitable for 10+ year goals only, RD better for < 5 year goals with capital protection priority), Debt Mutual Fund SIPs (7-9% but market risk, NAV fluctuates daily, interest rate risk—when RBI hikes rates, debt fund NAV falls, exit load 1% if sold before 3 years vs. RD no exit load after 3 years), Recurring Deposit Mutual Funds (hybrid debt funds with SIP, 7-8% returns but taxable @ 12.5% LTCG vs. RD taxable @ slab rate—for 31.2% bracket, RD post-tax 4.61% < debt fund post-tax 7% × (1-0.125) = 6.13%, BUT debt fund has market risk + lock-in for LTCG tax benefit, RD safer for risk-averse), and Gold SIPs (10-12% historical but volatile, no guaranteed returns, 3% GST + making charges eat into returns, storage risk—RD provides yield, gold doesn't pay interest!). RD calculator quantifies exact return differences—₹10k/month for 5 years in various options shows PO RD balances safety (sovereign guarantee) + decent returns (6.7% risk-free) + liquidity (loan facility) better than alternatives for conservative savers prioritizing capital preservation. Particularly valuable for comparing senior citizen RD rates across post office (7.2%) vs. top banks (SBI 6.5%, HDFC 6.7%, ICICI 6.7%)—post office senior RD best deal for retirees seeking maximum safe returns for retirement income supplementation!
Frequently Asked Questions
Post Office Recurring Deposit (RD) current interest rate: 6.7% per annum (Q3 FY 2024-25) with quarterly compounding. Senior citizens (60+ years) get additional 0.5% premium, making it 7.2% for seniors. Rate revised quarterly by Ministry of Finance based on government security yields.
Comparison with Bank RDs:
- Interest Rates: Post Office RD typically offers 0.2-1.2% higher than most bank RDs. Major bank rates (Q3 2024-25): SBI 6.5%, HDFC Bank 6.5%, ICICI Bank 6.7%, Axis Bank 6.5%. Post Office 6.7% matches/beats all! On ₹10k/month for 5 years: Bank @ 6.0% = ₹6.98L vs. PO @ 6.7% = ₹7.11L—₹13,000 extra from PO!
- Senior Premium: Post Office offers uniform 0.5% extra for seniors (60+) on RD. Some banks offer 0.25-0.50%, some only on specific tenures. Post Office more senior-friendly—7.2% among highest safe returns for retirees!
- Safety: Post Office RD backed by sovereign guarantee (Government of India)—zero default risk. Bank RDs covered by DICGC insurance only up to ₹5L per bank. For large RD balances (₹10L+ accumulated after 5 years), Post Office safer.
- Compounding: Post Office RD interest compounded quarterly (every 3 months). Many bank RDs compound quarterly too, but some compound annually—quarterly compounding gives slightly higher effective returns.
- Tenure: Post Office RD currently 5 years mandatory (earlier 1/2/3-year options discontinued). Bank RDs offer 1/2/3/5/10-year tenures—more flexibility. However, PO RD can be extended after 5 years in 5-year blocks.
- Convenience: Bank RDs have online deposit facility (auto-debit from savings account), net banking access, instant statements, mobile app tracking. Post Office RD requires branch visit for monthly deposit (unless Internet Banking enabled for select accounts)—less convenient but manageable for disciplined savers.
- Loan Facility: Both offer loan against RD. Post Office: 50% of balance after 12 months @ RD rate + 2% (e.g., 6.7% RD → 8.7% loan). Banks: 50-90% of balance @ 2-3% over RD rate. Banks slightly better loan terms.
- Premature Closure: Post Office RD: After 3 years, 1% interest penalty. Bank RDs: Varies (some after 6 months, penalty 0.5-1.5%). Banks more flexible.
When to Choose Post Office RD:
- Higher Returns Priority: Extra 0.2-1.2% matters over 5 years—₹10k/month earns ₹13k-40k more in PO vs. banks.
- Senior Citizens: 7.2% (with 0.5% premium) often beats bank senior RD rates (6.5-6.75%)—best deal for retirees.
- Maximum Safety: Sovereign guarantee preferred over bank DICGC ₹5L insurance, especially for large RD corpus (₹7L+ after 5 years on ₹10k/month).
- Government Institution Trust: Prefer post office over private/PSU banks for long-term 5-year commitment.
- Rural/Semi-Urban Access: Post office branch more accessible than private banks in villages/small towns.
When to Choose Bank RD:
- Online Convenience: Need auto-debit (set once, forget), net banking access, mobile app tracking—avoids monthly branch visits.
- Tenure Flexibility: Want 1/2/3-year RD (shorter than PO's mandatory 5 years) for near-term goals.
- Integrated Banking: Prefer RD linked to salary account, single-window banking services, easier fund transfers.
- Better Loan Terms: Some banks offer 80-90% loan against RD (vs. PO 50%) at competitive rates.
Effective Return (6.7% Quarterly Compounded): Post Office RD 6.7% compounded quarterly = 6.87% effective annual rate. Formula: (1 + 0.067/4)^4 - 1 = 6.87%. However, due to progressive deposit nature (Month 1 deposit earns interest for 60 months, Month 60 deposit earns for 1 month only), actual wealth gain percentage lower than FDs where lump sum earns from Day 1. ₹10k/month × 60 months = ₹6L deposits → ₹7.11L maturity = 18.5% absolute gain over 5 years (₹1.11L interest / ₹6L deposits). Annualized return ~3.5% (simple) or ~6.7% (IRR considering monthly deposits timing). Still better than savings account 3-4% and safer than equity 12-15% volatile!
Yes, premature withdrawal allowed after 3 years (36 months) from RD opening date. However, penalties apply reducing your interest earnings.
Premature Withdrawal Rules:
- Before 3 Years (36 Months): Premature closure NOT allowed under normal circumstances. Exception: Death of account holder (nominee can close anytime without penalty, gets maturity amount at contracted rate).
- After 3 Years (36+ Months): Withdrawal permitted with 1% interest penalty. Interest recalculated at rate applicable for tenure completed, minus 1%.
- Example 1: ₹10k/month 5-year RD @ 6.7% closed after 4 years (48 months) → Total deposits ₹4.8L, interest recalculated @ 5.7% (6.7% - 1% penalty) instead of 6.7%. You receive ₹5.41L (₹4.8L deposits + ₹61k interest @ 5.7%) vs. ₹5.69L if held full 5 years (₹89k interest @ 6.7%). Loss = ₹28,000 interest!
- Example 2: ₹5k/month 5-year RD @ 6.7% closed after 3 years exactly (36 months) → Deposits ₹1.8L, interest @ 5.7% (6.7% - 1%) = ₹18,400. You get ₹1.98L vs. ₹2.06L if closed after 3.5 years or ₹2.14L if closed after 4 years. Longer you hold, less penalty impact (more months at contracted rate before penalty applied).
- No Penalty Cases: (a) Death of account holder—nominee/legal heir gets full maturity at contracted rate without penalty, anytime. (b) Court order directing closure. (c) Government directive for specific cases (rare).
Discontinuation vs. Premature Closure (Different!):
- Discontinuation: If you miss 4+ consecutive monthly deposits, RD account becomes "discontinued" (not closed, just inactive). You can withdraw accumulated deposits + reduced interest (rate for period deposits remained in account). Example: ₹5k/month RD, deposited 24 months (₹1.2L), then missed 6 months → Account discontinued. You get ₹1.2L deposits + interest for 24 months @ post office savings rate (4%) = ₹1.24L approx. Very low interest because discontinued early!
- Revival: Discontinued RD can be revived by paying all missed deposits + ₹1 penalty per ₹100 deposit per month delayed. Example: Missed 6 months of ₹5k deposits = ₹30k arrears + penalty ₹1,800 (₹300/month × 6 months) = ₹31,800 to revive. Expensive but worth it if RD close to maturity (say 48 months completed, only 12 months left).
Better Alternative to Premature Withdrawal—Loan Against RD:
Instead of closing RD prematurely, consider loan against RD (available after 12 months):
- Loan Amount: Up to 50% of accumulated balance (deposits + interest earned till date). After 4 years (₹4.8L deposits in ₹10k/month RD + ₹72k interest = ₹5.52L balance) → ₹2.76L loan available.
- Interest Cost: RD rate + 2% (e.g., 6.7% RD → 8.7% loan). Net cost 2% since RD continues earning 6.7% (8.7% loan - 6.7% RD = 2% effective cost).
- Comparison: Premature withdrawal (as Example 1 above) loses ₹28k interest. Loan of ₹2.76L @ 8.7% for 1 year = ₹24k interest cost, but RD continues earning ₹38k (6.7% on ₹5.52L balance) = net cost ₹24k - ₹38k = -₹14k (you actually profit!). Plus RD matures to full ₹7.11L at Year 5 after loan repaid. Loan better if liquidity need temporary (6-18 months).
- Repayment Flexibility: No fixed EMI—repay anytime. If not repaid by maturity, loan + interest auto-deducted from maturity amount.
Strategic Tips to Avoid Premature Withdrawal:
- Separate RDs for Different Goals: Instead of single ₹15k/month RD, open 3 RDs—₹5k each with different opening dates (Jan/Apr/Jul)—creates staggered maturity every 3 months after 5 years, providing periodic liquidity without breaking any RD.
- Emergency Fund Separate: Don't mix emergency funds with goal-based RD. Keep 6-12 months expenses (₹3-5L) in savings account or 1-year FD (easy liquidity). Use RD only for committed goals (child education, home down payment)—reduces forced premature RD closure for emergencies.
- Start with Lower Deposits: If uncertain about sustaining ₹15k/month for 5 years (income volatility, job change risk), start with ₹5k-8k/month RD (easily manageable). Can open additional RD if income increases later. Better than starting ₹15k, discontinuing after 2 years (lose interest + goal disrupted).
- Reduce Deposits Instead of Closure: If income drops mid-tenure, don't close RD! Pay lower deposits + ₹1 penalty (e.g., pay ₹3k instead of ₹10k committed + ₹7 penalty/month). Penalty ₹84/year vs. losing ₹28k by premature closure! RD continues, just accumulates slower. Not officially allowed but some post offices accommodate during genuine hardship.
Tax Impact of Premature Withdrawal: Interest earned (even if reduced due to penalty) is fully taxable in year of withdrawal under "Income from Other Sources". If TDS was deducted during RD tenure (quarterly on interest accrued), excess TDS refunded during ITR filing based on actual interest received at closure. No additional penalty from tax perspective, just reduced interest = lower tax liability.
Post Office RD Interest Calculation: Unlike FDs (lump sum earning interest from Day 1), RD involves progressive monthly deposits earning interest for varying periods. Interest compounded quarterly but credited at maturity along with principal.
RD Formula (Simplified for Understanding):
Maturity Amount (M) = P × [((1 + r/n)^(n×t) - 1) / ((1 + r/n)^(1/3) - 1)]
- P = Monthly deposit amount (e.g., ₹10,000)
- r = Annual interest rate (decimal, e.g., 6.7% = 0.067)
- n = Compounding frequency per year (4 for quarterly)
- t = Tenure in years (e.g., 5)
Why RD Formula Complex vs. FD?
- FD (Lump Sum): Simple formula M = P × (1 + r/4)^(4t). ₹6L deposited Day 1 earns interest for full 5 years (1,825 days). Straightforward compounding.
- RD (Progressive Deposits): ₹10k deposited each month—Month 1 deposit earns interest for 60 months (1,825 days), Month 2 for 59 months (1,795 days), ..., Month 60 for only 1 month (30 days). Each deposit has different time value! Formula must account for this progressive nature where later deposits earn proportionally less interest than earlier deposits.
- Result: ₹6L in RD (₹10k × 60 months) earns ₹1.11L interest over 5 years. Same ₹6L in FD earns ₹2.68L interest (@ 7.5% FD rate, higher than RD 6.7%). FD wins because lump sum compounds from Day 1 vs. RD's last deposit compounds only 30 days!
Step-by-Step RD Calculation Example:
₹5,000 monthly deposit, 5 years (60 months), 6.7% annual rate (quarterly compounding):
- Step 1: Total Deposits = ₹5,000 × 60 months = ₹3,00,000
- Step 2: Apply Formula = ₹5,000 × [((1 + 0.067/4)^(4×5) - 1) / ((1 + 0.067/4)^(1/3) - 1)]
- Step 3: Calculate = ₹5,000 × [((1.01675)^20 - 1) / ((1.01675)^0.333 - 1)]
- Step 4: Simplify = ₹5,000 × [(1.394 - 1) / (1.0055 - 1)] = ₹5,000 × [0.394 / 0.0055]
- Step 5: Result = ₹5,000 × 71.636 = ₹3,58,180 maturity
- Step 6: Interest Earned = ₹3,58,180 - ₹3,00,000 = ₹58,180
- Wealth Gain = (₹58,180 / ₹3,00,000) × 100 = 19.4% over 5 years
Quarterly Compounding Advantage:
- Quarterly Compounding: Interest calculated every 3 months, added to principal for next quarter. ₹5k/month RD @ 6.7% quarterly = ₹3.58L maturity (as above).
- If Annual Compounding: Same RD with annual compounding = ₹3.52L maturity. ₹6,000 less! Quarterly compounding wins due to interest-on-interest effect 4 times/year vs. once/year.
- Effective Annual Rate: 6.7% quarterly compounded = 6.87% effective. Formula: (1 + 0.067/4)^4 - 1 = 6.87%. Slightly higher than nominal 6.7%.
Interest Payment Timing:
- Credited at Maturity: Interest NOT paid out during RD tenure (unlike some bank RDs offering monthly interest payout option). Interest compounds internally and credited to your Post Office Savings Account along with principal at maturity (60th month).
- No Monthly Income: If you need monthly income, RD not suitable—consider Post Office Monthly Income Scheme (POMIS) instead (₹9L max deposit, 7.4% rate, ₹5,735/month income). RD designed for lump sum goal achievement (child's school fees in Year 5, home down payment), not regular income.
- Passbook Tracking: Post Office provides RD passbook showing each month's deposit entry, running balance, but interest accrual not shown monthly (calculated at backend quarterly, appears at maturity).
Tax on Interest (Important!):
- Taxable Annually: Interest accrued is taxable every year as "Income from Other Sources" even though you don't receive interest till maturity! Post Office calculates pro-rata interest yearly for TDS/tax reporting.
- TDS Rules: TDS @ 10% deducted if annual interest exceeds ₹40,000 (₹50,000 for seniors). ₹10k/month RD annual interest ~₹18k-24k (varies by year due to progressive deposits)—typically no TDS. But ₹20k/month RD or multiple RDs combined can trigger TDS from Year 3-4 onward.
- Form 15G/15H: Submit to post office if total income below taxable limit to avoid TDS deduction. Applicable for both below-60 (Form 15G) and 60+ seniors (Form 15H).
- ITR Filing: Report RD interest in ITR under "Income from Other Sources" even if TDS not deducted. For ₹5k/month RD earning ₹58k total interest over 5 years, report ~₹11,600 annual average (varies by year—Year 1 ~₹4k, Year 5 ~₹18k due to compounding effect).
RD vs. FD Interest Comparison (Same Total Amount):
- Scenario: ₹6L invested—RD (₹10k/month × 60 months) vs. FD (₹6L lump sum upfront).
- RD: ₹10k/month @ 6.7% for 5 years = ₹7.11L maturity (₹1.11L interest, 18.5% gain).
- FD: ₹6L lump sum @ 7.5% for 5 years = ₹8.68L maturity (₹2.68L interest, 44.7% gain).
- FD Wins IF: You have ₹6L lump sum available Day 1 (inheritance, bonus, property sale). FD earns ₹1.57L more interest than RD because full ₹6L compounds from Day 1.
- RD Wins IF: You earn monthly salary and can only save ₹10k/month (no ₹6L upfront). RD is ONLY option—can't do FD without lump sum! For salaried class, RD enables wealth creation from monthly surplus vs. waiting years to accumulate ₹6L for FD (by then opportunity cost huge!).
Bottom Line: RD formula complex due to progressive deposits (each month's deposit has different compounding period). RD returns lower than FD for same total amount because later deposits earn less interest. However, RD's monthly deposit nature suits salaried individuals without lump sum capital—enables systematic wealth creation through disciplined savings. Use RD calculator to estimate accurate maturity—hand calculations prone to errors due to quarterly compounding on progressive deposits!
Yes! Post Office offers loan facility against RD from 12 months (1 year) after opening till maturity, providing emergency liquidity without breaking RD and losing interest.
Loan Terms & Eligibility:
- Eligibility Period: Available from 12 months (1 year) after RD opening date—must have completed minimum 12 monthly deposits to qualify. Not available before 12 months or after RD matures.
- Loan Amount: Up to 50% of accumulated balance (total deposits made + interest earned till date). Example: ₹10k/month RD, after 24 months—deposits ₹2.4L + interest ₹16k = ₹2.56L balance → Loan ₹1.28L available (50% of ₹2.56L). After 48 months—balance ₹5.52L → Loan ₹2.76L available.
- Multiple Loans: Can take loan against multiple RDs simultaneously if you have multiple RD accounts (no limit on number of RD loans).
- Joint RD: All joint holders must consent for loan (signatures of all holders required on loan application).
Interest Rate on Loan:
- Formula: Loan Interest = RD Interest Rate + 2% (higher markup than FD loan @ FD rate + 1%).
- Examples:
- RD @ 6.7% → Loan @ 8.7%
- Senior citizen RD @ 7.2% → Loan @ 9.2%
- Net Cost: Since your RD continues earning its interest rate (6.7%) while you pay loan interest (8.7%), net cost 2% (8.7% loan - 6.7% RD earning = 2% effective cost).
- Example Calculation: ₹1L loan @ 8.7% for 1 year = ₹8,700 interest cost. RD balance continues earning—if ₹2L balance @ 6.7% = ₹13,400 earned. Net impact: ₹8,700 loan cost vs. ₹13,400 RD earning = ₹4,700 net gain! BUT this assumes you borrowed only ₹1L from ₹2L balance (50%). If borrowed full ₹1L against ₹2L, net cost = ₹8,700 loan - ₹6,700 RD earning on ₹1L portion used for loan collateral = ₹2,000 (2% of ₹1L).
Repayment Terms:
- No Fixed EMI: Unlike personal loans, RD loan has no mandatory monthly EMI. Interest calculated daily on outstanding principal.
- Flexible Repayment: Repay anytime—full or partial. Can repay ₹20k today, ₹30k after 3 months, balance after 6 months—complete flexibility based on cash flow.
- Auto-Deduction at Maturity: If loan not repaid before RD maturity (60th month), loan principal + accrued interest automatically deducted from maturity amount. Example: ₹10k/month RD matures to ₹7.11L at Year 5, loan outstanding ₹2L + interest ₹35k = ₹2.35L → You receive ₹7.11L - ₹2.35L = ₹4.76L net. Goal corpus reduced if loan unpaid—plan repayment before maturity to preserve full goal amount!
- No Prepayment Penalty: Zero penalty for early/full repayment of RD loan anytime (unlike many personal loans charging 2-5% prepayment fee).
Loan Against RD vs. Other Emergency Loan Options:
| Loan Type | Interest Rate | Eligibility | Amount | Repayment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RD Loan | 8.7% (RD rate + 2%) | After 12 months | 50% of balance | Flexible, no EMI |
| FD Loan | 8.5% (FD rate + 1%) | After 6 months | 95% of deposit | Flexible, no EMI |
| Personal Loan | 10-16% | Credit score, income proof | ₹50k-₹25L | Fixed EMI, 1-5 years |
| Gold Loan | 9-12% | Gold jewelry as collateral | 75% of gold value | Bullet/EMI options |
| Credit Card | 36-42% (EMI convert) | Existing card holder | Up to card limit | Minimum payment/EMI |
When to Take RD Loan:
- Medical Emergency: ₹1-2L needed urgently for surgery, hospitalization—RD loan @ 8.7% approved same day at post office vs. personal loan taking 3-7 days + 12-16% rate.
- Income Disruption: Job loss, salary delay, business income gap—borrow against RD to maintain household expenses while searching for new job/income recovery, repay once stable.
- Child's Education Fees: School admission requires ₹1.5L suddenly (before RD maturity)—loan preserves RD goal (child's higher education at Year 5), repay loan from bonus/increment.
- Home Repairs: Urgent house damage (roof leakage ₹80k, plumbing ₹40k)—RD loan cheaper than personal loan, repay within 6-12 months from salary.
- Avoid Credit Card Debt: If emergency expense currently on credit card (36-42% interest!), immediately take RD loan @ 8.7% to pay off card, save ₹27-33% interest difference!
When NOT to Take RD Loan (Prefer Other Options):
- Non-Essential Expenses: Vacation, gadget purchase, luxury item—don't disturb goal-based RD for wants. Use separate savings/bonus money.
- Long-Term Needs: Home purchase (₹10L+ needed for years)—RD loan max ₹2-3L and must repay before RD maturity (1-3 years left). Better to take home loan for long-term need.
- If FD Available: If you have both RD and FD, prefer FD loan (95% of deposit @ FD rate + 1% = 8.5%) vs. RD loan (50% of balance @ RD rate + 2% = 8.7%). FD loan higher amount + slightly cheaper rate.
- RD Close to Maturity: If RD maturing in 3-6 months, just wait instead of taking loan (avoid loan interest cost). Use credit card/personal loan temporarily if essential, repay immediately from RD maturity.
How to Apply for RD Loan:
- Visit post office where RD account opened (must be same branch).
- Check eligibility: (a) RD completed 12+ months? (b) Accumulated balance sufficient for needed loan (50% loan available)?
- Fill loan application form (available at post office counter).
- Submit: RD passbook + identity proof (Aadhaar/PAN) + loan application.
- If joint RD, all holders must sign loan application and visit branch together.
- Loan amount credited to Post Office Savings Account or linked bank account within 1-2 days (same day in many branches if processed before 2 PM).
- Repayment: Cash deposit at post office counter OR cheque/online transfer to loan account (loan account number provided after approval). No auto-debit from savings account (must manually pay).
Important Cautions:
- Goal Disruption Risk: If loan not repaid before RD maturity, goal corpus reduced (₹7.11L maturity - ₹2.35L loan outstanding = ₹4.76L net). If RD earmarked for child's college fees (₹7L needed), loan reduces available amount below requirement—plan repayment to preserve goal!
- Limited Loan Amount: 50% of balance restrictive—₹2.5L balance allows only ₹1.25L loan. If ₹2L needed, can't borrow from single RD (vs. FD allowing 95% = ₹2.375L). May need to borrow from multiple RDs or supplement with personal loan.
- Monthly Deposits Continue: Taking loan doesn't excuse monthly RD deposits! Must continue depositing ₹10k/month even while servicing loan (avoid discontinuation penalty). Ensure cash flow can handle both loan repayment + ongoing RD deposits simultaneously.
"Better" depends on your goal timeline, risk appetite, capital preservation priority, and return expectations. Both serve different purposes—RD for short-term capital-protected goals, SIP for long-term wealth creation. Here's a detailed comparison:
Post Office RD vs. Equity SIP:
| Factor | Post Office RD | Equity SIP (Mutual Funds) |
|---|---|---|
| Returns | 6.7% guaranteed (7.2% senior), fixed | 12-15% average historical (1980-2024), volatile |
| Risk | Zero—sovereign guarantee, capital protected | High—market risk, can be -30% to +50% annually |
| Ideal Tenure | 1-5 years (short-medium term) | 10+ years (long-term wealth creation) |
| Tax Treatment | Interest taxable @ slab rate (10.4-31.2%) | LTCG @ 12.5% on gains > ₹1.25L (after 1 year) |
| Liquidity | Loan 50% after 12 months, premature closure after 3 years | Redeem anytime (T+1/T+3 days), no lock-in |
| Minimum Investment | ₹100/month (extremely accessible) | ₹100-500/month (fund dependent) |
| Best For | Risk-averse, capital protection priority, short goals | Risk-takers, wealth maximization, long goals |
Wealth Creation Comparison (₹10,000/month for Different Tenures):
3-Year Scenario:
- RD: ₹10k/month × 36 months @ 6.7% = ₹3.85L maturity (₹25k interest, 6.9% gain). Guaranteed ₹3.85L—predictable.
- Equity SIP: ₹10k/month × 36 months @ 15% average = ₹4.12L IF market performs well. BUT high volatility risk—could be ₹3.4L (if -20% year) to ₹4.5L (if +30% year). Problem: If goal in Year 3 (child's school admission) and market crashes Year 2.5 (like COVID March 2020 -40%!), corpus drops to ₹2.8L—₹1.05L shortfall vs. goal! Must postpone admission OR arrange emergency funds—unacceptable for critical goals.
- Verdict for 3 Years: RD wins—capital protection + predictability > higher volatile returns for short tenure. SIP unsuitable for < 5 years (market volatility too high, insufficient time for recovery).
5-Year Scenario:
- RD: ₹10k/month × 60 months @ 6.7% = ₹7.11L maturity (₹1.11L interest, 18.5% gain). Safe, guaranteed.
- Equity SIP: ₹10k/month × 60 months @ 15% average = ₹8.82L—₹1.71L more than RD! BUT still volatile—5-year CAGR could be 8-22% (₹7.4L-₹9.8L range). If market flat/negative Years 4-5 (like 2011-2013 Nifty stagnation), corpus may underperform RD!
- Verdict for 5 Years: Borderline—SIP starts showing advantage IF risk appetite moderate + goal can be delayed 1-2 years if market crashes near maturity. RD still safer for inflexible goals (home down payment deadline, child's college admission Year 5 fixed).
10-Year Scenario:
- RD: ₹10k/month × 120 months @ 6.7% = ₹16.63L maturity (₹4.63L interest, 38.6% gain). Predictable but modest.
- Equity SIP: ₹10k/month × 120 months @ 15% average = ₹27.48L—₹10.85L more than RD (65% higher!). Even conservative 12% CAGR = ₹22.8L (₹6.17L more than RD). Volatility smoothens over 10 years—even if Years 8-10 crash, earlier years' gains cushion portfolio. Historical data: 10-year rolling returns (Nifty 1995-2024) show 95%+ instances beat FD/RD returns!
- Verdict for 10+ Years: SIP wins decisively—compounding power + long tenure smoothens volatility. RD's safe 6.7% can't compete with equity's 12-15% over decade. Only exception: Extremely risk-averse retirees with zero earning capacity (can't recover losses if market crashes Year 9-10).
When to Choose Post Office RD:
- Short-Term Goals (1-5 years): Child's school admission, car purchase down payment, wedding expenses, home appliances, vacation fund—goals with fixed deadlines where shortfall unacceptable.
- Capital Protection Priority: Risk-averse investors unable to tolerate 30-40% portfolio drops (retirees, single-income families, debt-averse individuals). Sleep-at-night factor important.
- Guaranteed Income Needs: Know exactly ₹7.11L available after 5 years for down payment (already committed to property, can't delay if market crashes). Predictability > higher volatile returns.
- First-Time Investors: Never invested before, intimidated by stock market complexity, prefer simple "deposit ₹X/month, get ₹Y guaranteed" approach. RD builds confidence before graduating to equity SIPs.
- Debt-Free Philosophy: Conservative families avoiding all forms of risk (no stocks, no bonds, only government-backed schemes). RD suits their risk profile.
When to Choose Equity SIP:
- Long-Term Wealth (10+ years): Retirement planning (age 30 → 60), child's higher education (newborn → age 18), building ₹1Cr+ corpus—time horizon sufficient to ride market volatility + benefit from compounding.
- Higher Return Appetite: Willing to tolerate -20% to -40% drawdowns in bad years for potential 15-25% gains in good years. Focus on long-term average (12-15%) vs. yearly fluctuations.
- Inflation Beating: Need returns > inflation (6-7%) to preserve purchasing power. RD 6.7% barely beats inflation—real return ~0%. SIP 12-15% provides 5-8% real return after inflation.
- Tax Efficiency: High-income earners (31.2% bracket)—RD post-tax 4.61% vs. SIP post-LTCG ~10.5% (12% return × 12.5% tax = 10.5% net). SIP 2x better post-tax efficiency!
- Flexible Goal Timeline: Goal can be delayed 2-3 years if market crashes near target (e.g., retirement can extend 62 to 65 if portfolio down, not rigid 60).
Optimal Strategy—Combine Both (Diversification!):
- Age 30, Salary ₹1L/month, Surplus ₹30k:
- ₹10k/month → RD (for car down payment in 3 years, capital protection)
- ₹15k/month → Equity SIP (for retirement in 30 years, wealth maximization)
- ₹5k/month → PPF (for tax-free long-term savings, Section 80C)
- Age 50, Salary ₹1.5L/month, Surplus ₹50k, Retiring 60:
- ₹20k/month → RD (for medical emergency fund by 55, safe corpus)
- ₹20k/month → Debt Mutual Fund SIP (for retirement corpus by 60, moderate risk 7-9%)
- ₹10k/month → Equity SIP (for long-term post-retirement growth 60-75, limited exposure)
Final Verdict: Post Office RD best for short-term capital-protected goals (1-5 years) where predictability critical. Equity SIP best for long-term wealth creation (10+ years) where compounding + time smooth volatility. DON'T choose one over other—allocate based on goal timeline! Short goals → RD (safety), Long goals → SIP (growth), Medium goals → Debt SIP/Balanced Funds (moderate). Diversification across tenure + risk profiles optimizes wealth creation + capital protection + goal achievement probability!